With only 2 lb of Weyermann smoked malt, this one goes down easier than you would expect for a smoked beer. I used S04 and turned out fine. I would suggest drinking this beer no colder than 50F, really brings out the mild roasted flavor of the carafa. Take out of the fridge and let site for 20 minutes. Wait 4 weeks to drink from bottling. Good head retention and lacing. A bit lighter in color and mouthfeel than one would expect in a porter. I split the LME into early and late to get better bittering, you'll end up with about 40 IBUs. The smoked malt will not have a smoked taste or smell, but rest assured, it will smoke the beer. This is the type of beer you homebrew for, something that is hard to find otherwise. You really can’t compare to Shlenkerla, that beer has very intense, heavy smoke, leather, and bacon flavor, hard to drink in my opinion. This is a good smoked beer to get your feet wet.